Second DePuy ASR Hip Replacement Lawsuit Trial Underway After First Trial Resulted in $8.3 Million Award, Reports Wright & Schulte


The second DePuy ASR Hip Replacement Lawsuit Trial is currently underway in Illinois following the close of the first trial that resulted in an $8.3 million award for the plaintiff in Los Angeles, California Trial.

DePuy-ASR-Hip-Replacement-Injuries-LawyerWright & Schulte LLC, an experienced medical device injury law firm is reporting that the litigation against the DePuy ASR hip replacement is continuing with the second DePuy ASR hip replacement recall lawsuit injury trial currently underway in Illinois. The first completed DePuy ASR hip replacement injury trial ended recently with the plaintiff being awarded $8.3 million in damages against DePuy.( Kransky v. DePuy, BC456086, California Superior Court, Los Angeles County) The second DePuy ASR hip replacement hip trial is currently underway in Illinois state court. (Strum v. DePuy, 2011-L-9352, Circuit Court of Cook County)

Wright & Schulte LLC offers free case evaluations to any individuals who suffered serious Depuy ASR hip replacement recall complications and symptoms, including:

  • revision surgery and/or pain
  • swelling
  • inflammation
  • implant loosening
  • clicking in the hip
  • bone deterioration
  • tissue death (necrosis)
  • metallosis (toxic levels of metal in the body)
  • pseudotumors caused by fluid-filled masses near the joint, or
  • hip failure

Second DePuy ASR Hip Replacement Implant Injury Trial Update

The trial currently underway in Illinois Cook County Circuit Court is the second of more than 10,700 DePuy ASR hip replacement recall injury lawsuits to be heard in court. This DePuy ASR hip replacement injury lawsuit was brought by a 54-year-old Illinois nurse who claims that her DePuy ASR hip replacement device allegedly failed after only three years, causing her to undergo revision surgery. In the lawsuit, the plaintiff also alleges that DePuy failed to warn consumers and physicians about the risks of the metal-on-metal DePuy ASR hip replacement device. According to Bloomberg, the plaintiff alleges that DePuy knew the design of the DePuy ASR replacement hip was defective and could cause the device to shed metal particles into the patient’s body, causing necrosis and high levels of metal ions in the blood. (

DePuy argued that the plaintiff had “an extremely lengthy and significant medical history,” that included autoimmune problems, and claimed that it was not known why some people have a negative reaction to devices. DePuy claims that the plaintiff’s “individual biology and health issues were the cause of the revision, not the device,” Bloomberg writes. The Illinois trial continues into its second week.

First DePuy ASR Hip Implant Trial

In the first DePuy ASR hip replacement injury trial, plaintiff Loren Kransky alleged that J&J executives were aware of a critical design flaw in the DePuy ASR hip replacement device years before they issued a massive recall. Kransky alleged that J&J concealed information regarding the flaw from consumers and their physicians, including that they knew it could shed large quantities of metal debris into the body and that it failed internal tests in 2007, the New York Times reports. In that case, the jury found the DePuy ASR hip is defective, but that DePuy did not act with malice or fraud. The jury awarded the plaintiff $338,000 in medical costs and $8 million in damages for pain and suffering. (

DePuy ASR Recall

DePuy recalled the ASR hip replacement devices in 2010, after selling more than 93,000 of them worldwide. At the time, the recall was initiated due to early failure rates. The company issued a statement claiming the DePuy ASR XL was properly designed and that DePuy’s actions regarding the product and the recall were “appropriate and responsible.” Since that time, nearly 11,000 DePuy ASR XL replacement hip lawsuits have been filed in courts across the country against DePuy alleging early failure rates, tissue necrosis, metallosis, and revision surgery. (

About Wright & Schulte LLC

Wright & Schulte LLC, an experienced defective medical device injury firm, is dedicated to the belief that America’s legal system should work for the people. Every day, the attorneys of Wright Schulte LLC stand up for the rights of people who have been injured or wronged, and fight tirelessly to ensure that even the world’s most powerful corporations take responsibility for their actions. If you’re looking for a law firm that will guarantee the aggressive and personal representation you deserve, please do not hesitate to contact Wright & Schulte LLC today. Free DePuy ASR hip replacement recall lawsuit case evaluations are available through, or call 1-1-800-399-0795.

This entry was posted in Recalls, Wright & Schulte LLC News. Bookmark the permalink.